Justice S.N. Riechi rules that Harrison Mawia’s resignation as MCA was valid, lifting orders that had halted the November 17 election.
The High Court in Kitui has dismissed a petition seeking to block the Migwani Ward by-election, handing the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) the green light to resume preparations for the delayed poll.
In a judgment delivered on Wednesday, November 19, 2026, Justice S.N. Riechi dismissed a petition filed by voter Francis Musili Kauta, ruling that the resignation of former Migwani MCA Harrison Maluki Mawia was valid and that the electoral commission had acted within the law.
📊 Channel 15 News Opinion Poll
The decision effectively lifts conservatory orders issued on October 22, which had compelled the IEBC to suspend the by-election that was scheduled for November 17.
The court directed the commission to resume the electoral process from the stage it had reached before the suspension. However, the judgment did not specify a new election date.
The ruling clears a major legal hurdle that had thrown the Migwani Ward by-election into uncertainty, with the commission now expected to determine the next steps towards filling the vacant seat.
Court upholds Mawia’s resignation
The legal dispute stemmed from Mawia’s resignation on August 5, 2026, to take up the position of Clerk of the Kitui County Assembly. His appointment was subsequently gazetted on August 6.
Kauta challenged the process, arguing that there were questions surrounding the transparency and timing of Mawia’s resignation, particularly whether he had formally relinquished his MCA position before the County Assembly deliberated on his recruitment.
He further sought to have the by-election suspended or deferred to the August 2027 General Election, arguing that conducting a separate poll would amount to unnecessary expenditure of public resources.
However, Justice Riechi found that Mawia’s resignation letter, which bore a receiving stamp from the Speaker’s office dated August 5, constituted a valid resignation under Article 194(1)(d) of the Constitution.
The court held that the letter demonstrated a clear intention by Mawia to vacate his seat, paving the way for the Speaker to formally notify the IEBC of the vacancy.
It further found that the Speaker had followed the prescribed procedure in communicating the vacancy to the electoral commission.
The petitioner, the court ruled, had failed to demonstrate that the notification was unlawful or based on false information.
KSh32 million election expenditure defended
The cost of conducting the by-election also featured prominently in the petition, with the IEBC informing the court that it had set aside approximately KSh32 million for the exercise.
Kauta had questioned the justification for spending the money on a standalone ward election when the country was scheduled to hold the next General Election in August 2027.

Photo: Courtesy | The Judiciary of Kenya
But the court found that the petitioner had not provided evidence demonstrating that the proposed expenditure was imprudent.
In defending the constitutional requirement to fill vacant elective positions, the judge observed that democracy comes at a cost but remains worth protecting.
The law requires the IEBC to organise elections to fill vacant seats, except where a vacancy occurs within three months of a General Election.
During cross-examination, Kauta acknowledged that Mawia’s resignation letter existed and that resignation was a recognised constitutional mechanism through which an elective seat could become vacant.
Mawia, in his testimony, told the court that he personally delivered the resignation letter to the Speaker and did not participate in the County Assembly’s deliberations concerning his recruitment.
Voter registration affected by court orders
Beyond the delayed by-election, the legal battle had also disrupted continuous voter registration in Migwani Ward.
The IEBC told the court that the suspension of the electoral process had stalled voter registration in the ward, leaving eligible residents who were not registered unable to enlist as voters ahead of the August 8, 2027 General Election.

Photo: Courtesy
The court, however, did not delve into the legality of Mawia’s recruitment as County Assembly Clerk, noting that the matter was already the subject of separate proceedings before the Employment and Labour Relations Court in Machakos.
With the petition now dismissed and the conservatory orders lifted, the IEBC is expected to resume preparations for the Migwani Ward by-election.
The court directed that each party bear its own costs.

